Circles Co Studio Search

Meet Halo, our AI website builder, run by real people. Get your website built today

← All insights General · Mar 29, 2019 · 4 min read

When to hire an outside marketing team instead of an in-house marketer

How to decide between an outside marketing team and an in-house hire: the real costs, the signs each one fits, how to choose a team and how to work well together.

Four coworkers gather around a wooden table reviewing printed documents together in a warm, casual workspace
Photo: Andreea Avramescu on Unsplash

Most small businesses reach a point where marketing needs more hours than the owner has. The website needs fresh pages, the newsletter has gone quiet, and the flyer for next month’s event still isn’t designed. The usual next thought is to hire someone. Sometimes that is the right call, and sometimes an outside team gets you further for the same money.

This guide walks through how to tell which one fits your business right now, what each option really costs, how to pick a good outside team if you go that way, and how to work with them so the work keeps moving.

What an outside marketing team actually does

An outside team is a small group of specialists you share with other clients: usually a writer, a designer, someone who handles the website, and a person who keeps projects on schedule. You pay for a set amount of their time each month, or for defined projects, instead of a salary.

The work can include website updates, emails, print pieces, ads, social posts, photography direction and simple reporting on what is working. The key difference from a hire is breadth. One employee brings one person’s skills. A team brings several, and you only pay for the slice you use.

Compare the real cost, not just the salary

A salary is the visible number, but it is not the whole cost of an in-house marketer. Before you compare, add up everything the role brings with it:

  • Pay and taxes. Salary plus payroll taxes, benefits and paid time off.
  • Tools. Design software, a stock photo plan, an email platform, scheduling tools and a capable computer.
  • Hiring and training. The weeks spent recruiting and the months before a new person knows your customers.
  • Gaps in skill. Most marketers are strong at writing or design, rarely both, so you may still pay outside help for the other half.
  • Turnover. When a solo marketer leaves, the passwords, files and know-how often leave too.

Now price an outside team for the same scope of work. For many businesses with one location or a modest budget, the team costs less and covers more. Once you need someone at the shop every day, the math can flip.

Signs an outside team is the better fit

An outside team tends to make sense when one or more of these is true for you:

  • The work is varied but not full time. You need a little design, a little writing and some website care each month, but not 40 hours of any one of them.
  • You need skills you can’t judge. If you can’t tell a good designer from an average one in an interview, a team with a portfolio removes that guesswork.
  • Your marketing comes in waves. Seasonal businesses, churches with big holiday events and nonprofits with an annual fundraiser often need a lot for six weeks, then very little.
  • You want it to keep going. A team covers vacations and sick days, so the newsletter still goes out.

When hiring in-house is the smarter move

An outside team is not always the answer. Hire your own person when marketing is tied to daily, on-site work: filming events as they happen, running the front-desk social account, or answering customer messages within minutes. Hire when you have enough steady work for a full-time role and someone on staff can manage them well. And hire when your brand depends on deep product knowledge that takes a long time to learn.

Many businesses end up with both. An in-house coordinator handles the daily voice and the photos from the floor, while an outside team takes on the website, design and bigger campaigns. That split often gets the best of each.

How to choose the right outside team

Look for proof, not promises. Ask to see work for businesses close to yours in size, and ask what changed for those clients after the work went live. A few more questions worth asking:

  1. Who will do the work? Meet the people, not just the salesperson.
  2. What is included each month? Get it in writing, including how many rounds of changes you get.
  3. How fast do they respond? Agree on a normal turnaround for small requests and for big ones.
  4. Who owns the files? Your logo files, photos, website logins and domain should be yours, in your name, from the start.
  5. How do you leave? A fair agreement has a clear notice period and hands everything back cleanly.

If a team can’t answer these plainly, keep looking.

How to work well together once you start

The best outside teams still need you for the things only you know: your customers, your offers and what is coming up. A short monthly plan keeps everyone pointed the same way. Our guide to writing a simple marketing plan is a good place to start one.

  • Name one point person. One person on your side approves work, so feedback doesn’t arrive from five directions.
  • Share the calendar early. Tell the team about events, sales and announcements at least a few weeks ahead.
  • Give feedback in one pass. Collect everyone’s notes, then send them together.
  • Review results monthly. Look at website visits, form fills and calls, and decide together what to do more or less of.

If most of your need is design, a retainer may be a better match than a full team. Our piece on how a design retainer works explains the difference.

Your next step

This week, write down every marketing task you did or skipped last month, roughly how many hours each one took, and which skills it needed. Total the hours and look at the list. If it is under full time and spread across writing, design and the website, get a quote from an outside team and compare it to the full cost of a hire. If it is full time and tied to your location, start writing the job description.

If you want a second opinion on that list, Circles Co works as an outside team for small businesses, churches and nonprofits, and we are glad to tell you honestly whether a hire would serve you better.